Necrotising Fasciitis

The college loves this condition, and it crops up rather regularly.

  • Question 2 from the second paper of 2016 (Group A Strep and diagnosis of necrotising fasciitis)
  • Question 25 from the first paper of 2016 (a diabetic leg)
  • Question 3.2 from the first paper of 2014 (necrotising fasciitis of the abdominal wall)
  • Question 24 from the first paper of 2011 (another diabetic leg)
  •  Question 14.1 from the second paper of 2010 (Fourniers)
  • Question 25.1 from the first paper of 2009 (necrotising fasciitis of the abdominal wall)
  • Question 1 from the first paper of 2001 (a non-diabetic leg

The significance of Group A Streptococci (GAS)  in necrotising fasciitis

Without digressing into deep dark microbiology, one may summarise the issues in the following manner:

  • S.pyogenes is the sole member of the Lancefield Group A. The use of the term GAS has generally  been superceded by more advanced methods of classification, as the number of streptococci species has massively exploded in the last thirty years.
  • S. pyogenes produces enzymes such as hyaluronidase, which digest the fascia.
  • It also produces superantigen toxins, which lead to streptococcal toxic shock syndrome.
  • Most S.pyogenes infections are sensitive to benzylpenicillin
  • Large doses may be required due to the Eagle effect

Risk Factors for Necrotising Fasciitis

 

Comorbid conditions

  • Immunosuppression
  • Diabetes
  • Chronic disease
  • Corticosteroids
  • Malnutrition
  • Age > 60
  • Intravenous drug use
  • Peripheral vascular disease
  • Renal failure
  • Underlying malignancy
  • Obesity

Aetiological factors

  • Blunt or penetrating trauma
  • Soft tissue infections
  • Surgery
  • Intravenous drug use
  • Childbirth
  • Burns
  • Muscle injuries

Diagnosis of necrotising fasciitis

The definitive resource for this is probably Wong et al (2005). However, much of the summary below actually comes from the 1995 article by McHenry et al, and represents the historical and clinical features found in a retrospective case series of necrotising fasciitis patients.

Features of history

  • Rapidly develping symptoms
  • Reasonably young patients
  • Previously healthy
  • History of minor trauma, eg. scratch, bruise
  • Initial injury is frequently trivial and blunt rather than penetrating
  • Intense pain and tenderness over the involved skin and underlying muscle
  • Pain is out of proportion to physical findings
  • Risk factors may be apparent: diabetes, alcoholism, obesity, steroid use.
  • Usually, the use of NSAIDs is reported (Aronoff et al, 2003)

Features of physical examination

  • At the earliest stages, necrotising facsiitis is indistinguishable from severe cellulitis.
  • Severe pain on palpation is an early feature
  • The affected tissue is oedematous and has a "wooden, hardened feel"
  • Erythema is present early.
  • Skin "blebs", i.e. bullae with clear fluid develop as skin ischaemia progresses, and these become haemorrhagic in a late presentation
  • Crepitus on palpation is another late sign
  • Decreased sensation of the overlying skin develops late in the course, and the skin may appear clearly gangrenous

Biochemical features

  • Acute renal failure
  • Coagulopathy; DIC
  • Raised inflammatory markers (WCC, CRP)
  • Hypocalcemia
  • Metabolic (lactic) acidosis
  • Rapid antigen detection test for Group A Strep: this is mainly for pharyngitis (Gerber et al, 2004), but has been used to achieve a rapid diagnosis of lifethreatening GAS soft tissue infection (Ault et al, 1996)
  • "Streptozyme" tests; which, according to a 2009 book chapter by Gould and Reeves are "generally not helpful except as paired acute and convalescent titres", which means the patient will be long dead if you wait for these to become diagnostic of necrotising fasciitis. Oh well, here'es a list of theem anyway, directly from Question 2 from the second paper of 2016
    • Anti-streptolysin (ASO) 
    • Anti-hyaluronidase (AHase) 
    • Anti-streptokinase (ASKase) 
    • Anti-nicotinamide-adenine dinucleotidase (anti-NAD) 
    • Anti-DNAse B antibodies

Radiological appearance

  • CT findings:
    • Deep fascial thickening
    • Contrast enhancement
    • Fluid and gas in the soft tissue planes in and around the superficial fascia
  • Ultrasound findings:
    • Thickening and distortion of the deep fascia
    • Fluid collections along the deep fascia
  • MRI findings
    • Deep fascial thickening
    • Deep fascial fluid collections
    • Hyperintense T2W signal within the muscles

Surgical findings

  • The presence of grayish necrotic fascia
  • A lack of resistance to blunt dissection: i.e. the normally firmly adherent superficial fascia just sort of falls apart under gentle traction your hands.
  • Lack of bleeding of the fascia during dissection
  • The presence of foul smelling ‘dishwater’ pus.

Histopathology

  • The histologic criteria for diagnosis as described by Stamenkovic and Lew (1984) were as follows:
    • Necrosis of the superficial fascia
    • Polymorphonuclear infiltration of the dermis and fascia
    • Fibrinous thrombi of arteries and veins coursing through the fascia
    • Angiitis with fibrinoid necrosis of arterial and venous walls
    • Presence of microorganisms within the destroyed fascia and dermis
    • An absence of muscle involvement.

Microbiology

  • S.pyogenes is frequently the organism found on tissue culture
  • Blood cultures are also frequently positive

Management of necrotising fasciitis

The key factors in its management:

  • Source control
  • Broad spectrum antibiotics
  • Clindamycin
  • IV immunoglobulin
  • Hyperbaric oxygen

Source control

Broad-spectrum antibiotics

IV immunoglobulin

  • IV immunoglobulin is a valid strategy in streptococcal toxic shock syndrome; though the investigators of the linked study didn't reach statistical significance in their primary endpoit (mortality), they did note a significant decrease in organ failure scores in the IVIG group.
  • Encouraged by such evidence, people have also used polyspecific immunolgobulin to manage necrotising fasciitis, or to moderate its systemic effects, to be more precise. In actual fact, the abovelinked study features patients whose surgical management was conservative, and of whom the majority did have toxic shock syndrome anyway.
  • The already-mentioned retrospective audit from Victoria had also suggested that people with severe soft tissue infections benefit from IVIg irrespective of whether they ahve toxic shock syndrome or not. The addition of polyspecific immunoglobulin to clindamycin reduced mortality from 15% to 7%, even though these patients were on average sicker, with more organ dysfunction.

Hyperbaric oxygen

  • The college answers to their necrotising fasciitis questions make one think that a referral to a hyperbaric centre is a mandatory part of management. However, this management strategy historically did not seem to reduce either mortality or the number of debridements. Some encouraging recent data suggests that they were doing it wrong in the 1990s, and modern hyperbaric oxygen therapy seems to be associated with a 50% reduction in mortality (from 9.4% to 4.5%). However, in spite of such findings, experts remain devoid of enthusiasm, and the recent (2015) Cochrane meta-analysis did not find any trials which might have met its inclusion criteria. All in all, hyperbaric oxygen remains a brilliant treatment looking for a disease.

Necrotising fasciitis of the abdominal wall: a specific scenario

For some reason this keeps coming up in the exam (Question 25.1 from the first paper of 2009 and Question 3.2 from the first paper of 2014). Specifically, the college keeps asking about the Gram-positive rods in the blood culture (it turns out to be a Clostridium species).

According to an authoritative source, "postoperative necrotizing fasciitis of the abdominal wall is usually caused by peritonitis in patients who have undergone multiple procedures for complications of emergency laparotomy".

However, the typical case will present as a polymicrobial zoo, and whereas Clostridium species will likely flourish in the smelly pockeds of avascular fat necrosis, it is unlikely that they will be found in the blood culture, particularly as the blood is so well oxygenated (much of the time). It is more likely that Clostridium perfringens would the sole organism in the cultures of a patient with gas gangrene of the abdominal wall. If the college mentioned subcutaneous emphysema of the abdominal wall, there would be no guesswork involved in this question. This is supported by an article from 1966 (back in the day when surgeons actually palpated people's abdomens instead of scanning them). It reports on ten patients; nine had proper crackly gas gangrene due to C.perfringens or C.multifermentans. One patient with a C.tertium infection only had abdominal wall cellulitis, just like in the college question.

Cancer-related perforations followed by necrotising fasciitis of the abdominal wall do exist in case report literature. One case from the UK reported early debridement so aggressive that it left some small bowel and kidney on show (that time, β-haemolytic strep was responsible).

 

References

Marron, Conor D., et al. "Perforated carcinoma of the caecum presenting as necrotising fasciitis of the abdominal wall, the key to early diagnosis and management." BMC surgery 6.1 (2006): 11.

Casali, Robert E., et al. "Postoperative necrotizing fasciitis of the abdominal wall." The American Journal of Surgery 140.6 (1980): 787-790.

Rea, William J., and Walter J. Wyrick Jr. "Necrotizing fasciitis." Annals of surgery 172.6 (1970): 957.

Samel, S., et al. "Clostridial gas gangrene of the abdominal wall after laparoscopic cholecystectomy." Journal of Laparoendoscopic & Advanced Surgical Techniques 7.4 (1997): 245-247.

McSwain, Barton, John L. Sawyers, and MARION R. Lawler Jr. "Clostridial infections of the abdominal wall: review of 10 cases." Annals of surgery 163.6 (1966): 859.

Hasham, Saiidy, et al. "Necrotising fasciitis.Bmj 330.7495 (2005): 830-833.

Mulla, Zuber D. "Treatment options in the management of necrotising fasciitis caused by Group A Streptococcus." Expert opinion on pharmacotherapy 5.8 (2004): 1695-1700.

Darenberg, Jessica, et al. "Intravenous immunoglobulin G therapy in streptococcal toxic shock syndrome: a European randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial." Clinical infectious diseases 37.3 (2003): 333-340.

Brown, D. Ross, et al. "A multicenter review of the treatment of major truncal necrotizing infections with and without hyperbaric oxygen therapy." The American journal of surgery 167.5 (1994): 485-489.

Soh, Chai R., et al. "Hyperbaric oxygen therapy in necrotising soft tissue infections: a study of patients in the United States Nationwide Inpatient Sample." Intensive care medicine 38.7 (2012): 1143-1151.

Majeski, James A., and J. Wesley Alexander. "Early diagnosis, nutritional support, and immediate extensive debridement improve survival in necrotizing fasciitis." The American Journal of Surgery 145.6 (1983): 784-787.

Bilton, Bradley D., et al. "Aggressive surgical management of necrotizing fasciitis serves to decrease mortality: a retrospective study." The American Surgeon 64.5 (1998): 397-400.

Wong, Chin-Ho, et al. "Necrotizing fasciitis: clinical presentation, microbiology, and determinants of mortality." The Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery 85.8 (2003): 1454-1460.

Norrby-Teglund, Anna, et al. "Successful management of severe group A streptococcal soft tissue infections using an aggressive medical regimen including intravenous polyspecific immunoglobulin together with a conservative surgical approach." Scandinavian journal of infectious diseases 37.3 (2005): 166-172.

Carapetis, Jonathan R., et al. "Effectiveness of clindamycin and intravenous immunoglobulin, and risk of disease in contacts, in invasive group A streptococcal infections." Clinical Infectious Diseases (2014): ciu304.

Levett, Denny, Michael H. Bennett, and Ian Millar. "Adjunctive hyperbaric oxygen for necrotizing fasciitis." The Cochrane Library (2015).

Eke, Ndubuisi. "Fournier's gangrene: a review of 1726 cases." British Journal of Surgery 87.6 (2000): 718-728.

Chelsom, J., et al. "Necrotising fasciitis due to group A streptococci in western Norway: incidence and clinical features." The Lancet 344.8930 (1994): 1111-1115.

McHenry, Christopher R., et al. "Determinants of mortality for necrotizing soft-tissue infections." Annals of surgery 221.5 (1995): 558.

Wong, Chin-Ho, and Yi-Shi Wang. "The diagnosis of necrotizing fasciitis." Current opinion in infectious diseases 18.2 (2005): 101-106.

Stamenkovic, Ivan, and P. Daniel Lew. "Early recognition of potentially fatal necrotizing fasciitis: the use of frozen-section biopsy." New England Journal of Medicine 310.26 (1984): 1689-1693.

Aronoff, David M., and Karen C. Bloch. "Assessing the relationship between the use of nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs and necrotizing fasciitis caused by group A streptococcus." Medicine 82.4 (2003): 225-235.

Young, Michael H., David M. Aronoff, and N. Cary Engleberg. "Necrotizing fasciitis: pathogenesis and treatment." Expert review of anti-infective therapy (2014).